Scottish Parliament has banned transgender women from female toilets based on biological sex, sparking fierce debate about rights, safety, and inclusion.
At a Glance
- Scottish Parliament ruled that bathrooms must be designated by biological sex, aligning with a recent UK Supreme Court interpretation of the 2010 Equality Act
- Presiding officer Alison Johnstone stated the policy aims to provide “confidence, privacy and dignity” for all building users
- New gender-neutral facilities are being installed as an alternative option
- Conservative politicians are pushing for nationwide implementation of similar policies
- Trans rights advocates have condemned the decision as “rushed, unworkable and exclusionary”
Biological Sex Designation Policy Takes Effect
The Scottish Parliament has implemented a new bathroom policy requiring facilities to be designated based on biological sex rather than gender identity. The change at the Holyrood parliament building follows a recent UK Supreme Court ruling interpreting the 2010 Equality Act, which confirmed that the terms “sex,” “woman,” and “man” refer specifically to biological sex. This ruling carries significant implications for how public spaces are managed throughout the United Kingdom and particularly impacts transgender individuals.
Effective immediately, transgender women will no longer be permitted to use women’s toilets in the Scottish Parliament building. The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) agreed to make “practical changes of minimal cost” to toilet and changing facilities. The new arrangements include establishing clearly designated female-only and male-only facilities, while also providing gender-neutral options to accommodate all users regardless of gender identity.
"Trans activists ‘in denial’ after Holyrood lavatory ban
Groups criticised over ‘ridiculous’ letter protesting ban on trans women using female facilities in Scottish Parliament
Scottish trans activists held a protest following the Supreme Court ruling
Trans activists are “in…
— Ronni Nicole #KPSS (@RonniNicole1) May 9, 2025
Leadership Emphasizes Dignity and Clarity
Presiding officer Alison Johnstone emphasized that the policy change aims to provide essential clarity for all building users. “Such clarity is an important element in offering all individuals confidence, privacy and dignity when using our facilities. Everyone working in, or visiting, Holyrood should feel welcome in the building and be confident there is a suitable facility for them,” Johnstone stated. The implementation includes converting a bank of three existing toilets into gender-neutral facilities that will be open to anyone.
“This examination of the language of the EA 2010, its context and purpose, demonstrate that the words ‘sex,’ ‘woman’ and ‘man’ in sections 11 and 212(1) mean (and were always intended to mean) biological sex, biological woman and biological man,” stated the U.K. Supreme Court.
Johnstone further explained, “We believe it is important to take these interim steps now not only to ensure we fulfil our legal responsibilities but to give clarity to all those using the building.” The SPCB has indicated it will continue to consult on additional changes to align with the updated Equality and Human Rights Commission code of practice. The new toilet arrangements went into effect Monday, with parliament officials implementing the changes swiftly following the ruling.
Political Response and Calls for Broader Implementation
The Scottish Conservatives have welcomed the parliamentary decision, with Conservative MSP Tess White urging First Minister John Swinney to expand similar policies nationwide.
“If the Scottish Parliament can respond to the Supreme Court judgement so swiftly, there is no excuse for John Swinney to keep dragging his heels. He must instruct all public bodies to uphold the law immediately instead of pandering to gender extremists,” said Tess White.
The decision has been met with strong opposition from transgender rights advocates, who argue the policy is exclusionary. Pro-transgender activist groups have criticized the decision as “rushed, unworkable and exclusionary.” Vic Valentine from the Scottish Trans and Equality Network expressed concern that the ruling would lead to exclusion and segregation for transgender individuals, though parliament officials maintain that the new gender-neutral facilities are designed to ensure all visitors and staff have appropriate access to bathroom facilities.
